How does the Chrysler Town & Country, one of Consumer Reports' least reliable cars on the market, earn a quality award? The same way a Volkswagen Tiguan, a car whose current generation garnered middling scores in J.D. Power and Associates' long-term dependability and short-term quality studies, does. San Diego-based Strategic Vision's released its Total Quality Awards on Monday. Some winners — the Toyota FJ Cruiser SUV and Tacoma pickup, the Kia Soul hatchback, the Lexus LS sedan — have high marks in other reliability studies. Others have anything but. That's because the firm calculates its Total Quality Index, which originated in 1995, by polling new-vehicle owners on problems experienced and satisfaction with numerous other aspects. In essence, it mixes leading reliability studies from Consumer Reports and J.D. Power with scores for product and dealership satisfaction — the sort of metrics J.D. Power gauges in its Automotive Performance, Execution and Layout and Sales Satisfaction Index studies. "A lot of quality scores out there simply count problems, and they have no way to be able to determine the importance of the various problems out there," Strategic Vision President Alexander Edwards told Cars.com. "We take a look at what are all the positive impacts plus the negative issues." Reliability issues can sink an individual model, Edwards said, but the quantitative differences between what's considered reliable and unreliable are so narrow today that owners draw their perceptions from minor aspects — a loose door handle, for example. Consumer Reports' Jake Fisher sees it differently. "Certainly, cars are more reliable these days than they were," said Fisher, the magazine's director of auto testing. But he cautioned that car shoppers have yet to enter an era where new cars are relatively problem-free."Problems have shifted," he said. "We are not seeing the major types of mechanical problems that we used to see." Instead, the publication observes "a lot of electrical issues, a lot of computer malfunctions," he said. "The last several years, we've probably seen an evening off of the reliability problems [and] just a shift of what goes wrong." Curiously, Chrysler's Town & Country is a snapshot of how Fisher characterized yesterday's cars. Consumer Reports has rated the minivan, along with its Dodge Grand Caravan sibling, well below average in terms of reliability for nine years in a row — for mostly mechanical, not electronic, reasons. The competing Honda Odyssey and Toyota Sienna, by contrast, rate average or better. Strategic Vision's Edwards disagrees. "The Chrysler Town & Country in the early 2000s was still better than the Hondas, [but] because the Honda brand name actually brought in this belief that the vehicle would be more reliable, perceptions of quality would switch over," Edwards said. "We've seen the Town & Country on a product side do very well over the past couple of years [in terms of quality]. It's the brand that was really holding off on the quality perceptions." It seems shoppers should avoid cars that plummeted in Strategic Vision's annual survey. Edwards was reluctant to discuss this year's losers, but BMW, Mercedes-Benz and Nissan are absent from the list. So are Mazda and Subaru — automakers that rank fourth and fifth, respectively, in Consumer Reports' latest 28-brand reliability survey. "When we publish things on our website, we just talk specifically about the vehicles that are leading," he said. "And [for] the vehicles that don't, we just don't give them any sort of attention." Here are the results of Strategic Vision's 1,000-point Total Quality Index.
Related from KickingTires http://blogs.cars.com/kickingtires/ | |||
| |||
| |||
|
Monday, May 13, 2013
Unlikely Winners Top Strategic Vision's 2013 Total Quality Awards
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Archive
-
▼
2013
(7180)
-
▼
May
(619)
- LeMons Colorado Inspections: AMC Onslaught, Wankel...
- Living With an EV for a Week – Day Two
- 2014 Chevrolet Impala 2.5 Driven: Spacious Meets P...
- 2013 Volkswagen Jetta TDI vs Jetta Hybrid
- Campaign Targets Child Heatstroke Deaths in Cars
- 2014 Chevrolet Malibu: A Quickie Makeover for the ...
- Subaru Running Low on 2014 Foresters
- Porsche 991 Targa Going Back To The Air Cooled Era
- 2014 Chevrolet Malibu: First Look
- PSA: Carsqa.com Is A Bunch Of Rotten Thieves – And...
- Meet The New ‘Bu, Same As The Old ‘Bu
- The Holden That Almost Became A Buick
- Derek And Doug’s Fantastic Crap Wagons: Mitsubishi...
- Two (Hundred) If By Sea: Crossing Lake Michigan on...
- Dark Days: Broken Hearts and Blown Gaskets
- Despite Overcapacity, Fiat Jobs Are Secured In Italy
- 2014 Mazda 6 vs. 2013 Honda Accord: Can Little Ol’...
- NHTSA Does Not Want Self-Driving Cars To Drive By ...
- Mark Templin Wants To Set New Lexus Record
- 2013 Hyundai Genesis: Family Checklist
- Junkyard Find: 1986 Ford LTD Country Squire LX
- Great Wall Wants To Out-Jeep Jeep
- Le Figaro: Renault And Mitsubishi Talking Tie-up (...
- First Drive: 2014 Acura MDX
- 2014 Acura MDX Starts at $43,185
- Cars.com Reviews the 2014 Acura MDX
- For the Jet-Ski Set: Acura Prices 2014 MDX Startin...
- 2014 Acura MDX First Drive: From the NSX People, t...
- Living With an EV for a Week – Day One
- 2015 Toyota Prius Spied: It’s What’s Under the Cov...
- Cheap(er) Fit EV: Honda Lowers the Lease Price to ...
- GM Pondering Silverado/Sierra Variants, Including ...
- Following Coda and Fisker, Spring of EV Carnage Cl...
- NHTSA Maps Strategies for Driverless-Car Safety
- 2014 BMW X5: First Look
- Honda Cuts Fit EV Lease Costs
- Cars.com Reviews the 2013 Porsche Panamera Hybrid
- The BMW X5: A Look Back
- What Keis And Big Pickups Have In Common: A Galapa...
- Dodge Journey Moving To Michigan, Toluca May Be Le...
- Honda Cuts Price on Fit EV
- Mmm . . . M5: 2000–03 E39 BMW M5 Buyer’s Guide [Ec...
- The Ultimate Self-Driving Machine, Now Available I...
- World’s Largest Automakers 2013: No Change Seen By...
- Refreshed Mazda CX-9 Doesn't Need to Change Third Row
- Musk Promises Triple The Superchargers, Transconti...
- Kampai! Japanese Make Ethanol From Straw
- Junkyard Find: 1977 Ford LTD Country Squire
- Fiat To Merge With Chrysler When VEBA Case Solved
- Piston Slap: Coming to Terms with an Old Soul
- Tax Saabotage: Muller And Saab Board (=Muller) Tar...
- John Phillips: Okay, So Maybe a Test Drive Isn’t S...
- 2013 Mercedes-Benz SL65 AMG Tested: Not the Fastes...
- 2014 Acura RLX: Car Seat Check
- Chevy Volt “starts to lurch forward, like my foot ...
- How Often Should You Check Your Engine's Oil?
- Vauxhall Dives Into GM Product Bin and Comes Up wi...
- 2014 BMW X5 Photos and Info: Less Weight and a Rea...
- 2014 Chevrolet Cruze Diesel Driven: Is This the an...
- Smartphone Apps Make for Spot-On Parking Management
- Toyota Bets Big On Big Data
- Cars.com Reviews the 2013 Toyota Sienna
- The Chevrolet SS We Should Have Gotten
- 2014 GMC Sierra Denali Photos and Info: Packing a ...
- Best Selling Cars Around The Globe: Who Is Really ...
- Introducing The Hongqi H7. Now At Your Neighborhoo...
- Tax Saabotage: Swedish Economic Crime Authority To...
- French Paper: PSA Low On Cash
- Can a Minivan Be Stylish?
- Junkyard Find: 1976 Ford LTD Country Squire
- Volkswagen Law Here to Stay – For Now
- Review: Toyota Camry SE 2.5L, Track Tested
- Tales From The Cooler: A Primer On That Primer-Lik...
- Generation Why: Finally, Some Hard Data Shows That...
- Dealer May Sell For Less
- Three Questions GM Should Answer
- Piston Slap: Crystal Ballin’ The Mighty Dak’s Tranny
- Aston Martin V12 Vantage Loses A Pedal, Refuses To...
- Hyundai Air Freshener Leaves Lasting Impression
- 2014 Aston Martin V12 Vantage S Debuts, Follows Fa...
- A Little Context From A Forgotten Photograph
- 2014 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 5.3L 4×4 Crew Cab Te...
- Name That Shifter, No. 130
- NHTSA Looking Into Possible Ford F-150 EcoBoost V-...
- Stress Tester: How to Test a Car’s Handling Withou...
- Livin’ Large: 2014 Fiat 500L Starts at $19,900
- 2013 Porsche 911 Carrera 4S Cabriolet Video
- 2013 Porsche 911 Carrera 4S Cabriolet Video
- Four-Hundred and How Many Horses? Chevrolet Finall...
- Tesla Wants To Build A Leaf Competitor
- 2014 Corvette Stingray Rated at 455 Horsepower
- Can Bob Lutz and the Chinese Save Fisker?
- Cadillac CTS-V Wagons Made Up 0.005 Percent Of CTS...
- Surprising Japanese Exports: American Jobs
- Tales From The Cooler: Instant Karma Depreciation
- Hawaii Lays Down Law on Texting While Driving
- We, The People, Want Hybrid SUVs
- Iran Khodro Looking To Build Cars In Iraq
- Inside The Industry: An Unsung Hero Recalls How A ...
- Car Crash Deaths Higher for Young Women
-
▼
May
(619)
No comments:
Post a Comment