This is a post that I'd rather not write. As a Detroiter, in an ideal world I'd rather that the domestic auto manufactures made tons of money selling great cars. I'm willing to take an unvarnished look at them, after all, those of us who live here are more likely to have some kind of personal interaction with the auto industry than most folks who live elsewhere, but I don't feel the need to gratuitously slam GM, Ford and Chrysler the way some people do. I just want to be fair. In addition, it grates on me when people accuse TTAC of having a bias against those three Detroit based car companies. Sure, we're not cheerleaders, but the writers and editors at TTAC don't have conference calls or Skype sessions where we choose which of the domestic automakers we'll slam that day. So it's with some reluctance that I have to note what I considered to be a couple of quality control issues with the all new Lincoln MKZ, now finally arriving in dealerships after a botched launch.
It was FoMoCo itself that raised the issue of quality control concerning the new MKZ. In explaining why dealers didn't have cars that were heavily promoted with Super Bowl level marketing, Ford said that their Hermosillo, Mexico plant, which assembles the MKZ and the Ford Fusion, couldn't keep up with a quality control procedure that was originally intended to prevent some of the quality stumbles that have plagued Ford launches of late. Every single MKZ was supposed to be rigorously inspected. The issue was compounded by supplier issues and missing parts. When Hermosillo couldn't keep up, uninspected cars were shipped to the Flat Rock, Michigan facility for those inspections, end-of-line repairs and installation of those parts. A while back Ford announced that all of those issues were resolved, that the Hermosillo plant was now up to speed and that the pipeline was full and that dealers had normal inventory levels. The inventory announcement seemed to be accurate, at least as far as it looked at Dearborn's Jack Demmer Lincoln, the closest Lincoln store to FoMoCo's headquarters. I have to drive my mom to regular appointments at her ophthalmologist and I drive by the Demmer shop going and coming. Since I hate sitting in doctor's waiting rooms, I usually hang out at the nearby Automotive Hall of Fame or the Henry Ford Museum, but I'd been to both of those recently so I decided to check out the Lincoln dealership. I counted at least 40 MKZs in the main lot. A salesman told me they had about 100 in stock and were expecting another 100 in the next week or so. There appeared to be a nice mix of powertrains and prices ranging from 2.0 L Ecoboost FWD models in the mid to upper 30s and fully loaded 3.7 L V6 AWD models in the low 50s. I think it's a great looking car, though I think the interior of the competing Cadillac ATS is better executed. For some reason the MKZ's interior designers gave it downward sloping arm rests, which made reaching the window and mirror controls a stretch. Concerning the exterior at first I thought the stylish rear end would mean less than ideal accessibility to the trunk, but when the deck lid is up the opening is surprisingly large. It was when I was checking out the trunk that I noticed the first disquieting thing regarding QC. I lifted up the carpeted panel to check out the spare tire and I was struck by the sloppy application of seam sealer. Not only was it sloppy, it appeared to be overabundant. It was particularly noticeable because its brown color contrasted sharply with the car's silver paint. In recent years we've gotten used to small QC details being attended to, little things like avoiding overspray or preventing adhesives from oozing out of joints. The seam sealer on the MKZ reminded me of how things were 40 years ago in the U.S. car industry. Actually, the only other recent cars that I've noticed with such sloppy body sealer were the one's from China that BYD had on display a while back at the NAIAS. Overgenerous application of body sealer underneath a cover in the trunk is one thing, the other quality issue was literally right in front of my eyes as the cars sat on the showroom floor. There were a handful of MKZs in the showroom, but none had the model's distinguishing optional retractable glass roof. I'm not very tall, just 5'6″, so the roofline is not that far from eye level for me. When I was checking out the cars to see if they had glass roofs, looking at the steel roofs from the back of the car I noticed that at the tail end of the roof panel where the sheet metal is bent 90 degrees to create the well into which the back glass sits, at the corner where the roof panel meets the side rail the finish on the metalwork is not very neatly done. I don't know if it's too much body filler or poorly ground welds, but it was noticeable on every single MKZ without a glass roof. Some were worse than others, and the problem seemed to be more on the passenger side than on the driver's side but it was hard not to miss. When I realized it was on every steel roof MKZ, I took a few pics with my cell phone. Even without high resolution photos, you can see what I'm talking about. It's not like the glass roofed cars are perfect. The gaps between the glass panels are much wider than we've become used to with bodywork, at least a half inch or more and those gaps are filled with rubber that's dark grey but still contrasts a bit with the deeply tinted glass. Maybe I'm being picky but neither that rubber trim on the glass roofed cars, nor the metal finishing on the others look like they belong on $50,000+ cars. Since the sloppy metalwork appeared to be on all the MKZs that I saw that had metal roofs, if it really is a problem, and not me just being picky, then it's a problem with process or design. A reader once took issue with how I characterized a piece of loose wood trim on the car as a "glaring" issue in my review of the Chrysler 300 . I used that word because in an otherwise nearly flawless car, when wood starts falling off the dashboard, right in front of your face, the issue is indeed glaring. Other than the two issues that I've mentioned here, the fit and finish of the MKZs were fine, and for the reasons mentioned at the head of this post, I want to like the MKZ, but it's hard to ignore a problem when it's looking at you right in the eye. Disclaimer: I haven't checked the metalwork on all of the competing cars in the MKZ's class. Maybe they have flaws too. I didn't notice anything glaring on the ATS in the Cadillac showroom next door. Ronnie Schreiber edits Cars In Depth, a realistic perspective on cars & car culture and the original 3D car site. If you found this post worthwhile, you can dig deeper at Cars In Depth. If the 3D thing freaks you out, don't worry, all the photo and video players in use at the site have mono options. Thanks – RJS from The Truth About Cars http://www.thetruthaboutcars.com | |||
| |||
| |||
|
Friday, April 19, 2013
Lincoln MKZ Supply Issue Resolved, But What About Hermosillo’s Quality?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Archive
-
▼
2013
(7180)
-
▼
April
(593)
- Crapcan Central: We Drive Seven of the Worst Cars ...
- 100th Anniversary of Ford’s Assembly Line: How It ...
- Name That Exhaust Note, Episode 182
- Robert Brockway: Car Jousting—It’s Not Just For Gl...
- Engine Downsizing, For Reals: The 6.09-Cubic-Inch,...
- Dissected: In-Depth with the Updated 2014 Bentley ...
- 2012 Fiat 500 Sport Long-Term Wrap: America Is an ...
- 'Couldn't See the Sign' Is Top Excuse for Cops
- 2014 Acura RLX “Luxury, Luxury” Commercial: They W...
- Price Cuts in the Sports-Sedan Aisle: 2014 Lexus I...
- Infiniti Looks at Platform-Sharing GT Coupe and Fl...
- 2013 Hyundai Sonata Hybrid: First Drive
- 2013 Toyota RAV4 Earns IIHS Top Safety Pick Status
- First Official 2014 Mercedes-Benz S-class Photo Ap...
- GM Expands Safety Alert Seat to 2014 Sierra Lineup
- Next 911 Turbo Abandons The Manual
- 2013 Toyota Sienna Video
- Piston Slap: Fix my Bro-Ham, Sanjeev!
- Ex-Ford CEO Says Australian Car Industry Is Dead
- GM Prepares A Barrage Of New Cars, Hopes To Right ...
- Review: 2012 Nissan Sentra
- Fathers, Sons, Apples and Trees
- Junkyard-Found Chevy Tribal Sticker Leads To New M...
- Residual Value Miracle Aston Martin To Fetch Millions
- Even Back Home In Korea, Lying About Gas Mileage C...
- Analysts Predict Very Strong April Sales
- Winterkorn Not Worried About Billion Euro Porsche ...
- 2014 Mazda6: Second Take
- Airbags, Tailgates Are Targets Du Jour for Thieves
- Latest Harebrained LeMons Scheme: It’s A K Car, Pa...
- America’s Next Top Bubble: Delinquencies Down, Dea...
- Best Selling Cars Around The Globe: How Chinese br...
- New or Used? : The Blasphemy Of Accountancy Edition
- Hyundai’s Offensive “Pipe Job” Commercial Was Pull...
- 2014 Toyota 4Runner: Kickin’ It Body-On-Frame Style
- Kia Style: 2014 Kia Forte Sedan 2.0L Automatic Tested
- Name That Shifter, No. 126
- Media Reporting Tesla Model S As Plug-In Sales Cha...
- Cars.com Reviews the 2013 Jeep Wrangler and Unlimited
- Lexus Prices 2014 IS
- Really, Infotainment Isn’t So Bad
- “Skipping the Ignition Spark to Fire the Points” –...
- Monday Longevity Champion: Long Live The Leylands!
- 2014 Toyota 4Runner: First Look
- Recall Alert: 2013 Nissan Altima
- Recall Alert: 2012-2013 Honda Fit
- 2013 Hyundai Santa Fe: First Drive
- Review: 2013 Chrysler 300 SRT8 (Video)
- Boston Marathon Bomber’s Deadly Mistake: He Took A...
- Open Mouth, Insert Jackboot: Daimler Insults Its C...
- ATS Coupe, New Escalade On The Way
- Mercedes-Benz Confirms Diesel For C-Class – In 2 Y...
- China Cracks Down On Military Plate Abuse
- How to Remove A Sticker From Your Car
- Why Luxury Sales Could Thrive in 2013
- America’s Top Suzuki Dealer Switches To Subaru
- Opel Abandons Bochum Completely
- Piston Slap: Just Bought It, Now Gotta Sell It!
- 34th Aannual Association Of Handcrafted Automobile...
- Sunday At The Drive-In
- What Makes An Enthusiast These Days
- Most-Read Car Reviews of the Week
- The Other Jim Russell
- Cop Drives Classic Cop Car: 1972 Ford Galaxie 500
- Building The Right Car At The Right Time
- Most-Watched Videos of the Week
- Topless Hedonism: BMW M6, Porsche 911, Mercedes SL...
- Alfa Romeo Weighing Options for Next MiTo, Wants t...
- Volkswagen Golf MkVII Gets R Line Treatment—At Lea...
- Despite Warning Signs, Fed Kept Money Flowing to F...
- Car Redux
- The Continental: Greetings from Vienna with BMW, H...
- 2014 Chevrolet Stingray Coupe and Convertible Pric...
- 2013 Honda Civic Video
- C7 ‘Vette Just $2,000 More Than Outgoing Model
- Akerson Gets Millions More In Cash To Grease His Exit
- 2014 Corvette Gets Modest Price Bump
- Fiat 500XL Forgot Its Epi-Pen
- Volkswagen Announces 10-Speed Dual-Clutch Automati...
- Recall Alert: 2014 Subaru Forester
- QOTD: What Is The Most Misunderstood Vehicle On Th...
- Where Is Currency Manipulation When We Need It: Ja...
- Hyundai Creates Killer Ad, Does Not Want You To Se...
- Cars.com Family Reviews the 2013 Lexus RX 450h
- Junkyard Find: 1992 Dodge Shadow America
- Review: 2013 Dodge Avenger SE
- Nissan Micra Solves Renault’s Labor Problems
- Fisker Edges Closer to Bankruptcy as New Details E...
- Geely & Detroit Electric Announce Strategic Partne...
- Spring Showers Bring Summer Tires Back to Our Suba...
- Formula Golf Cart: The Twizy Renault Sport F1 Conc...
- NHTSA’s Distracted Driving Guidelines Actually Mat...
- 2014 Cadillac ATS Coupe Spy Photos: Fewer Doors, t...
- What Price Mediocrity? Well, the 2014 Nissan Versa...
- Fiat Group Developing V-8 Turbo-Diesel for Global ...
- Convertible Comparo: 2013 VW Beetle Turbo vs. 2013...
- Spark Ranger: 2014 Chevrolet Spark EV EPA Range, E...
- In Bid for More Global Appeal, Lexus Emphasizing D...
- Cars.com Reviews the 2013 Lexus LS 600h
- Fitch, Moody’s, Stand Alone As Subprime ABS Skeptics
-
▼
April
(593)
No comments:
Post a Comment