Despite a chorus of largely uncritical reporting, there is a growing contingent of those who question VW's claim that their new MQB modular architecture will bring about significant savings. The latest among them is Bernstein Research. A report by noted analyst Max Warburton (who recently authored the definitive study on Chinese cars) questions VW's claims and shows how MQB may be helpful, but not nearly as significant as VW claims. On the other hand, it's worth noting that these reports are meant for end-user investors, not necessarily industry types.
In theory, the MQB platform is a dream come true for any auto manufacturer, allowing a one-size-fits-all platform to span across their expansive product offerings and further increase economies of scale by offering both standardization and flexibility all in one neat package. From that perspective, it's easy to wonder "how can Volkswagen NOT save money?" And for a company like VW, which is arguably an industry leader in scale, 20 percent might even be an appropriate figure. Like any prudent business student, I began to question the numbers being disseminated from the company. 20 percent seemed too neat, too easy, and most of all, too tailor made for a largely unquestioning automotive press. My thoughts trailed back to my introductory finance class. One key consideration that should be taken into mind when analyzing company valuations is the optimism of those responsible for creating the financial models. Naturally, I figured 20% was the result of this phenomenon. If you think about it, it's tough to imagine, "VW Announces MQB to Save 2% of Costs," making a splash in the headlines. Bernstein Research's analyst report on MQB presents a more contrarian view. Overall, Bernstein was unimpressed with MQB, claiming that the benefits were "over-hyped." This viewpoint had differed so drastically from my initial research on modular platforms, which hailed them as the next wave of change and innovation in the automotive industry. How could this gap be reconciled? To fully understand and appreciate the report, I had to get into the mind of its intended end-user, an investor. The mindset of an investor is much different than that of a car enthusiast. While industry observers herald MQB as the next great leap forward for automotive manufacturing, an investor cares about one thing and one thing only:money. From an investor standpoint, if MQB cannot deliver any value though its stated cost savings and result increase company earnings, it is largely irrelevant. The report states, "There may be some savings from this [MQB], but they are likely to be very modest."[1] The modest nature of these savings stems from a number of sources. First, MQB does not help to lower a manufacturer's major fixed costs like raw materials, labour, and assembly hours. Remember that economies of scale, at its core, is the ability for a business to save money by spreading its fixed costs across a higher volume of production. This definition would lead to the assumption that by standardizing all of its platforms, VW will be able to cut costs throughout the supply chain by having their suppliers reach economies of scale. However, the report argues that past a production level of 1 million units, there begins to be diminishing returns. Bernstein explains, "scale economies are usually exhausted at the plant level rather than the firm level."[2] Since most OEMs are already at full scale, they already purchase parts from suppliers in some sort of economic batch size. In order for suppliers to save through economies of scale, they would have to increase their production. Since suppliers are also already at full scale, they would have to increase the capacity of their plants in order to increase their output. The capital expenditure related to increasing capacity, whether it is machines or labor, effectively negates any sort of cost saving that was originally sought after. Theoretically, if VW sourced its parts and raw materials from one centrally located monster plant, it would be much easier to realize these savings. VW's geographical diversification and localized sourcing makes this much harder to achieve, as each separate location has its own associated fixed costs. Think about it in terms of trying to house all of your cars in one mega garage, or in 10 separate garages across the city. The one mega garage has a single set of maintenance and utilities, which the latter option has 10. A more grounded figure for MQB's cost savings is somewhere in the neighborhood of 2%-5%, similar to what Renault-Nissan claimed. As mentioned above, 2% is not the most attractive number to unveil to the public, but this relatively small figure should not be dismissed completely. VW's costs of sales were over 157 billion euro in 2012. A 2% cost saving would translate to an additional 389 million euro in earnings before interest and taxes, or an addition 0.83 euro per share. Even on the lower end of estimations, it is clear that if MQB can help lower costs by any amount, it still helps to deliver value to VW and its shareholders. If you were to put $389 million in my pocket, I wouldn't be too upset. When considering the competitive nature of the automotive industry and the resulting intense margin compression that manufacturers face, the amount of cost savings are even more impressive. I like to think about it in terms of a Formula 1 race, in which the shaving of even a few milliseconds off of a car's lap time is a huge accomplishment. Success is relative, and numbers, whether they be tenths of a second or percentage points, are meaningless without context. Even if savings derived from MQB are under 2%, let alone 20%, it still provides a huge strategic advantage for a multinational auto manufacturer like VW. The ability to remain flexible across its product offering will allow VW to continue to serve existing and emerging markets, each with its own specific needs. It will be interesting to see if VW can effectively leverage MQB's capabilities in its implementation. The ability to "flex" plants quickly (from a Golf to a Tiguan for example) based on market demand is one aspect that has been barely mentioned, but could prove to be a significant advantage. Graeme Kreindler is an HBA Candidate at the Richard Ivey School of Business at The University of Western Ontario. TTAC thanks Max Warburton and Bernstein Research for providing the report. from The Truth About Cars http://www.thetruthaboutcars.com | |||
| |||
| |||
|
Thursday, April 18, 2013
EXCLUSIVE: Bernstein’s MQB Report In Full
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Archive
-
▼
2013
(7180)
-
▼
April
(593)
- Crapcan Central: We Drive Seven of the Worst Cars ...
- 100th Anniversary of Ford’s Assembly Line: How It ...
- Name That Exhaust Note, Episode 182
- Robert Brockway: Car Jousting—It’s Not Just For Gl...
- Engine Downsizing, For Reals: The 6.09-Cubic-Inch,...
- Dissected: In-Depth with the Updated 2014 Bentley ...
- 2012 Fiat 500 Sport Long-Term Wrap: America Is an ...
- 'Couldn't See the Sign' Is Top Excuse for Cops
- 2014 Acura RLX “Luxury, Luxury” Commercial: They W...
- Price Cuts in the Sports-Sedan Aisle: 2014 Lexus I...
- Infiniti Looks at Platform-Sharing GT Coupe and Fl...
- 2013 Hyundai Sonata Hybrid: First Drive
- 2013 Toyota RAV4 Earns IIHS Top Safety Pick Status
- First Official 2014 Mercedes-Benz S-class Photo Ap...
- GM Expands Safety Alert Seat to 2014 Sierra Lineup
- Next 911 Turbo Abandons The Manual
- 2013 Toyota Sienna Video
- Piston Slap: Fix my Bro-Ham, Sanjeev!
- Ex-Ford CEO Says Australian Car Industry Is Dead
- GM Prepares A Barrage Of New Cars, Hopes To Right ...
- Review: 2012 Nissan Sentra
- Fathers, Sons, Apples and Trees
- Junkyard-Found Chevy Tribal Sticker Leads To New M...
- Residual Value Miracle Aston Martin To Fetch Millions
- Even Back Home In Korea, Lying About Gas Mileage C...
- Analysts Predict Very Strong April Sales
- Winterkorn Not Worried About Billion Euro Porsche ...
- 2014 Mazda6: Second Take
- Airbags, Tailgates Are Targets Du Jour for Thieves
- Latest Harebrained LeMons Scheme: It’s A K Car, Pa...
- America’s Next Top Bubble: Delinquencies Down, Dea...
- Best Selling Cars Around The Globe: How Chinese br...
- New or Used? : The Blasphemy Of Accountancy Edition
- Hyundai’s Offensive “Pipe Job” Commercial Was Pull...
- 2014 Toyota 4Runner: Kickin’ It Body-On-Frame Style
- Kia Style: 2014 Kia Forte Sedan 2.0L Automatic Tested
- Name That Shifter, No. 126
- Media Reporting Tesla Model S As Plug-In Sales Cha...
- Cars.com Reviews the 2013 Jeep Wrangler and Unlimited
- Lexus Prices 2014 IS
- Really, Infotainment Isn’t So Bad
- “Skipping the Ignition Spark to Fire the Points” –...
- Monday Longevity Champion: Long Live The Leylands!
- 2014 Toyota 4Runner: First Look
- Recall Alert: 2013 Nissan Altima
- Recall Alert: 2012-2013 Honda Fit
- 2013 Hyundai Santa Fe: First Drive
- Review: 2013 Chrysler 300 SRT8 (Video)
- Boston Marathon Bomber’s Deadly Mistake: He Took A...
- Open Mouth, Insert Jackboot: Daimler Insults Its C...
- ATS Coupe, New Escalade On The Way
- Mercedes-Benz Confirms Diesel For C-Class – In 2 Y...
- China Cracks Down On Military Plate Abuse
- How to Remove A Sticker From Your Car
- Why Luxury Sales Could Thrive in 2013
- America’s Top Suzuki Dealer Switches To Subaru
- Opel Abandons Bochum Completely
- Piston Slap: Just Bought It, Now Gotta Sell It!
- 34th Aannual Association Of Handcrafted Automobile...
- Sunday At The Drive-In
- What Makes An Enthusiast These Days
- Most-Read Car Reviews of the Week
- The Other Jim Russell
- Cop Drives Classic Cop Car: 1972 Ford Galaxie 500
- Building The Right Car At The Right Time
- Most-Watched Videos of the Week
- Topless Hedonism: BMW M6, Porsche 911, Mercedes SL...
- Alfa Romeo Weighing Options for Next MiTo, Wants t...
- Volkswagen Golf MkVII Gets R Line Treatment—At Lea...
- Despite Warning Signs, Fed Kept Money Flowing to F...
- Car Redux
- The Continental: Greetings from Vienna with BMW, H...
- 2014 Chevrolet Stingray Coupe and Convertible Pric...
- 2013 Honda Civic Video
- C7 ‘Vette Just $2,000 More Than Outgoing Model
- Akerson Gets Millions More In Cash To Grease His Exit
- 2014 Corvette Gets Modest Price Bump
- Fiat 500XL Forgot Its Epi-Pen
- Volkswagen Announces 10-Speed Dual-Clutch Automati...
- Recall Alert: 2014 Subaru Forester
- QOTD: What Is The Most Misunderstood Vehicle On Th...
- Where Is Currency Manipulation When We Need It: Ja...
- Hyundai Creates Killer Ad, Does Not Want You To Se...
- Cars.com Family Reviews the 2013 Lexus RX 450h
- Junkyard Find: 1992 Dodge Shadow America
- Review: 2013 Dodge Avenger SE
- Nissan Micra Solves Renault’s Labor Problems
- Fisker Edges Closer to Bankruptcy as New Details E...
- Geely & Detroit Electric Announce Strategic Partne...
- Spring Showers Bring Summer Tires Back to Our Suba...
- Formula Golf Cart: The Twizy Renault Sport F1 Conc...
- NHTSA’s Distracted Driving Guidelines Actually Mat...
- 2014 Cadillac ATS Coupe Spy Photos: Fewer Doors, t...
- What Price Mediocrity? Well, the 2014 Nissan Versa...
- Fiat Group Developing V-8 Turbo-Diesel for Global ...
- Convertible Comparo: 2013 VW Beetle Turbo vs. 2013...
- Spark Ranger: 2014 Chevrolet Spark EV EPA Range, E...
- In Bid for More Global Appeal, Lexus Emphasizing D...
- Cars.com Reviews the 2013 Lexus LS 600h
- Fitch, Moody’s, Stand Alone As Subprime ABS Skeptics
-
▼
April
(593)
No comments:
Post a Comment