The revised fuel economy ratings for the Ford C-Max aren't the first time that an auto maker has been forced to backtrack on fuel economy claims – nor will it be the last unless meaningful reform is undertaken to ensure that fuel economy figures more accurately reflect the way motorists drive their cars in the real world.
The discrepancies between the EPA's fuel economy figures and what consumers can expect stem from a number of issues. For starters, manufacturers are allowed to self-report their findings, with the EPA only auditing about 10 to 15 percent of the vehicles on sale in any given year. There are all kinds of tricks that auto makers can use as well. In the case of the C-Max, Ford used data from its Fusion Hybrid to determine the C-Max's fuel economy, which lead to inflated ratings. While this may seem nonsensical to the outside observer, this is allowed under EPA guidelines, as the auto makers are only required to submit data for the volume model of any group of nameplates that use the same powertrain – even if they bear little to no relation to one another, as was the case here. EPA test procedures also contains no ethanol (which can have a positive impact on fuel economy), while the driving conditions used bear little resemblance to anything encountered in the real world. Tests are conducted on a dynamometer rather than on a real road, and 48.3 mph is considered "free-flowing traffic" on a freeway while city driving cycles use a barely-crawling speed of just 21.2 mph. Despite being utterly detached from reality, there is a good reason why the EPA fuel economy tests are designed this way. They aren't meant to really test fuel consumption. An article by Consumer Reports quotes one expert as stating that the tests
CR's own fuel economy tests revealed significant discrepancies between the EPA numbers and their own road test cycles, with the biggest culprits being small turbocharged 4-cylinder engines. These tend to do well on EPA tests, since the low speeds don't require much boost from the turbocharger. On the other hand, real world driving does require the turbo to work harder when driven at speeds above 21.2mph, which is how a car like the Lincoln MKZ, with a 2.0L 4-cylinder engine, can return 16 mpg in the real world despite being rated for 22 mpg by the EPA. With gas prices edging higher and fuel consumption becoming a priority among car shoppers, fuel economy tests have become increasingly importance for shoppers. Consumers compare "em-pee-gee" figures like they would have once looked at 0-60 mph times or crash test safety ratings, and rely on the EPA numbers to make purchasing decisions. Automotive marketing types know this, it's not unreasonable to assume that powertrain calibration has sometimes been designed specifically with the fuel economy testing procedures in mind. Being able to hit a "magic number" like 40 mpg highway is a marketing coup. But being exposed as unable to hit that number in real life is a tenfold embarrassment, as Ford and Hyundai both know. The current regimen of fuel economy tests have clearly outlived their usefulness.If the EPA test really is designed to measure emissions rather than fuel consumption, then that's a strong indication of how relevant their guidelines really are. The next step is, what should be done to bring them back to relevance? Can the EPA test process be reformed? Should there be an end to manufacturer reported figures? Or is it worth ignoring EPA figures from now on in favor of someone like Consumer Reports or even a self-reporting site like Fuelly?
from The Truth About Cars http://www.thetruthaboutcars.com | |||
| |||
| |||
|
Friday, August 16, 2013
Editorial: Time For Fuel Economy Reform
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Archive
-
▼
2013
(7180)
-
▼
August
(576)
- The World’s Best Sports Car Drivers All Run Into E...
- Chrysler Group Celebrates 30 Years of Minivans wit...
- What the Numbers on Your Tires Mean
- Which SUVs Are Easy to Get Into?
- Most-Watched Videos of the Week
- How to Choose the Right Tire
- Detroit Electric to Start Production in Holland, N...
- What’s Wrong With This Picture? Police Parking Ill...
- Which 2013 Car Is Similar to My 1991 Acura Integra?
- Junkyard Find: 1987 Toyota Conversion Van
- Review: 2014 Kia Cadenza (With Video)
- Nissan to Start Selling California ZEV Credits, Jo...
- As Fusion Builds Start at Flat Rock, Ford Consider...
- ZF and Levant Power Develop Regenerative Active Su...
- Recall Alert: 2005-2011 Ford, Lincoln and Mercury ...
- Throwing Money at Electrics: Automakers Are Losing...
- 2014 GMC Sierra 1500 5.3L 4×4 Crew Cab Tested: Det...
- 2014 BMW X5 M50d Diesel: Same Burly Tri-Turbo Engi...
- ZF Jointly Developing Energy-Recovery Suspension S...
- Cars.com Reviews the 2014 Chevrolet Corvette Stingray
- My Sister’s Story: The Road To Adulthood
- Review: 2013 Land Rover LR4
- Ford Modifies Mondeo, Will Sell Locally Built Edge...
- NHTSA Predicts Traffic Deaths Down in 2013
- Car and Driver on iPad: Our Typical Goodness, Only...
- Three's a Crowd With the Porsche 911's Steering Wh...
- 2013 Honda CR-V: Family Checklist
- The Truth About Tavares Slowly Slips Out
- Best Selling Cars Around The Globe: Puerto Ricans ...
- 2013 BMW X1: More Photos
- Answers: Missing Automotive Details
- Ford Snubs TTAC But – Hey, Bacon!
- Kia Niro Concept: Reaffirming the Brand’s Styling ...
- 2014 Chevrolet Malibu 2.5L Priced from $22,965, Ec...
- Holy Glow Plugs: 2014 Audi A6 and A7 Diesels Driven!
- Tread Rightly: What To Know Before Buying a Set of...
- 2014 Kia Cadenza “Luxury Features” Commercial: Mov...
- P-Cars And Perception
- In 2020, Nissan Will Drive You—But Will Anyone Let...
- 2014 Ford Mustang GT Convertible Video
- Kei Car Caper: Deep Inside Carol
- Ford Wraps Fiesta in Bacon, Really
- Volvo Concept Coupe: This is the Face of Future Vo...
- 2014 Kia Soul Starts at $15,495
- Next Week Is VW Intramural Week, And This Time The...
- 2013 Hyundai Azera: Car Seat Check
- Question: What Engine Swap Would Most Enrage Singl...
- TTAC “Blacklisted” By Ford Of Canada Due To Excess...
- Datsun Looking To Latin America, Africa For Expansion
- 2014 Honda Odyssey Earns IIHS Top Safety Pick+ Award
- Mitsubishi Without A Midsize Sedan For America
- Infiniti Q30 Concept Previews Compact Luxury Car
- Carlos Tavares Out At Renault
- Chief Engineer: Next Gen Prius Will Get Better Gas...
- Cars.com Names Top 10 Tailgaters
- Driven: 2014 VW Jetta with New 1.8-Liter Turbo Four
- Carry that Weight: GMC Releases New App with Trail...
- Kia Prices 2014 Soul Lineup, Base Car Starts at $1...
- New Jersey Appeals Court: Text A Driver, Share Fin...
- Porsche Makes The Scene At Adbusters, Linked To A ...
- Cars.com Reviews the 2013 Kia Sportage
- European Car Market Recovery 5-6 Years Out: Ford
- French Court Allows Sale of R134a Equipped Mercede...
- Everything’s Bedder in Texas: 2014 Chevy Silverado...
- Toyota’s Jim Lentz Testifies in Unintended Acceler...
- Nissan To Offer Autonomous Cars by 2020
- U.S. Dept. of Energy to Resume ATVM Alternative Ve...
- Name That Exhaust Note, Episode 196
- Ford Styling Chief: Lincoln “Not True Luxury”
- Editorial: The Future Is Here At Nissan – Just Not...
- Get a Whiff of Lincoln’s New Marketing Scheme
- Gas Prices Down Ahead of Labor Day Weekend
- Piston Slap: Such a Trooper!
- What to Drive to the World's Biggest Classic-Car C...
- How Long Should a Car's Light Bulbs Last?
- Ford Previews Next-Gen S-Max in Concept Form—It’s ...
- Eddie’s Money: The Story Behind the $27.5-Million ...
- 2015 Volkswagen e-Golf: Das (Electric) Auto [2013 ...
- 2016 Chevrolet Corvette Z07 Spied: Historic RPO Co...
- Infiniti Q30 Concept Mixes Compact Mercedes Platfo...
- Study: Fort Collins, Colo., Has Safest Drivers; D....
- Infiniti Q30 Concept Blends Coupe, Hatchback and C...
- 2013 Subaru BRZ: Road-Trip Report
- Video: We Talk Cadillac Elmiraj Concept with Clay ...
- 2014 Toyota Corolla Starts at $17,610
- Here’s Your New Lincoln Continental
- New Car Customer Satisfaction Down Slightly, Exper...
- Into the Gap: Three Cars Enter, Two Cars Leave
- Kia's Hamsters Hit the Gym With Lady Gaga
- Toyota To Keep Camry Prices Steady In Face Of Ford...
- Capsule Review: 2014 Kia Forte EX
- Junkyard Find: 1987 Nissan Stanza Wagon
- Detroit Electric Stalls Production Plans, Fisher B...
- What to Drive to Your High School Reunion
- 2013 Nissan Maxima: Car Seat Check
- China’s Geely Will Export Vehicles Jointly Develop...
- EPA: Blame Ford, Not Us, For C-Max Hybrids Not Rea...
- 2014 Toyota Corolla First Drive: Cranked Up to 11—...
- Corollin’ On Up: Toyota Prices 2014 Corolla from $...
- 2014 Nissan GT-R Track Edition Tested: Mechanical ...
-
▼
August
(576)
No comments:
Post a Comment